Bobby Bowen, a convicted criminal who is serving a life sentence in one of the state's prison, believes that the 1974 law clearly defines a life sentence being for the duration of 80 years and he further argues that the law combined with credits for good behaviour equates to the completion of his life sentence and he should now be released. In 1975, Bowen was convicted of two killings in Cumberland County and was initially sentenced to death. Later, the Supreme Court changed their sentence and removed Bowen from death. In exchange, Bowen received concurrent life sentences, and has sought but been denied parole since 1987. Most of the prisoners are in now in their 50's and 60's and are imprisoned for murder, sex offenses, and rape; seven have done time on death row.
According to the 1970's statute which was in effect for several years, ''a sentence of life imprisonment shall be considered as a sentence of imprisonment for a term of 80 years in the state's prison.''
In a statement, Thomas Bennett, Executive Director of the North Carolina Victim Assistance Network, advocates that releasing the prisoners is dangerous, and commented that ''this is terrible. This is a disaster. This is another example of victims not receiving consideration in the way the system works.''
Bennett added that “this will open new wounds and re-traumatize crime victims .These are bad actors. These are not people we want on the streets.''
Noelle Talley, spokesperson for Attorney Roy Cooper said that ''our lawyers have argued just about everything they can think of to keep this from happening. The Supreme Court has the final say.''
The North Carolina Supreme Court was not successful in overturning the states Court of Appeal's decision which re-examined life sentences for crimes committed during the 1970's. Consequently the duration of life sentences imposed before 1981 are cut in half and sentences for crimes committed in 1970s were reduced by 40 years.
The first 20 inmates are slated for release at the end of October, and another 10 inmates are expected to be released under the new guidelines over the next few years.